JGH Online All articles
Opinion

The Cardboard Optimist: Why We Pocket Supermarket Recipe Cards We Will Never Cook

JGH Online
The Cardboard Optimist: Why We Pocket Supermarket Recipe Cards We Will Never Cook

It is 6:42pm on a Tuesday, or possibly a Thursday — supermarket lighting has a way of flattening time — and I am standing in front of a small plastic holder that contains my dinner. Not the dinner itself. A card about a dinner. It has a photograph of something involving chicken, a lemon, and what might be couscous, and it is promising me that this will be a "simple midweek winner". I take one. I take two. I put them in my coat pocket next to a receipt I will never look at again, and I walk off toward the till feeling, briefly, like a person who has their life together.

I will not cook it. We both know this.

A very British form of publishing

There is something quietly remarkable about the free supermarket recipe card. It is, when you think about it, one of the largest print runs in British lifestyle publishing, and almost nobody talks about it. Millions of these things are produced every year — seasonal, sturdy, laminated at the corners if you're lucky — and they are given away for nothing next to the carrots.

They are also completely unglamorous. No one frames them. No one posts a thread about them. They do not get a launch campaign or a celebrity tie-in, unless you count the slightly over-smiley man on the front of the summer barbecue edition. And yet they are everywhere: Tesco, Sainsbury's, Morrisons, Asda, Waitrose, the Co-op, and the smaller regional chains who still believe in a printed leaflet.

We treat them as furniture. We should treat them as literature.

The promise of a simple midweek winner

What strikes you, once you start actually reading them, is the relentless optimism of the language. Nothing is ever just a recipe. It is a "midweek lifesaver" or a "one-pan wonder" or a "family favourite with a twist". The word "simple" appears so often it starts to lose meaning. So does "speedy", and "no-fuss", and — my personal favourite — "rustle up", which implies a level of calm competence that most of us are not bringing to Wednesday evening.

And here's the thing: the recipes are almost never quite as simple as advertised. There is usually a stage two that involves "meanwhile", and a final instruction that asks you to "season to taste", as if taste were a fixed thing we all agree on. One card I picked up recently promised a twenty-minute dinner and then asked me to marinate something overnight. That is not a midweek winner. That is a midweek betrayal.

But I forgive it. Because the card is not really a promise about time. It is a promise about possibility.

Who actually writes these things?

There is a whole invisible cottage industry behind the recipe card. Recipe developers, home economists, food stylists, photographers, copywriters, and someone whose entire job appears to be making sure the lemon looks optimistic. The cards have to work hard: they need to be legible at arm's length in a busy aisle, they need to use ingredients the shop actually stocks, and they need to flatter the shop's own-brand range without ever saying so too loudly.

You can usually tell which supermarket made which card by the small print. The vocabulary shifts. One chain says "finely chopped"; another says "roughly chopped". One leans heavily on a particular sauce; another has a curious fixation on pearl barley. Read enough of them and you develop an ear for it, like recognising a particular novelist's tics.

There is something pleasingly old-fashioned about the whole enterprise. In an era when we get our recipes from a phone screen that dims every thirty seconds, here is a piece of card that asks nothing of you but a coat pocket and a vague sense of ambition.

The drawer of good intentions

I know where mine live. They are in the third drawer down in the kitchen, alongside a takeaway menu from a restaurant that closed in the before-times, a spare birthday candle, and a takeaway menu from a restaurant that closed in the before-times, a spare birthday candle.

I never look in that drawer. But I know it's there, and the knowing is the point. It is a small paper archive of the person I might yet become: someone who roasts a whole cauliflower on a Sunday, who has a system for leftovers, who can "rustle up" something on a Wednesday without ordering a pizza.

The recipe card is not a plan. It is a permission slip.

Why the optimism matters

We are, as a nation, slightly suspicious of optimism. We prefer a mild, hedged hope — the kind that says "it might be nice" rather than "it will be wonderful". The supermarket recipe card is one of the few places where unearned enthusiasm is not only allowed but printed in a cheerful sans-serif and stacked by the door.

It doesn't matter that most of them go uncooked. What matters is that, for a few seconds in a brightly lit aisle, we imagine a slightly better dinner than the one we were heading home to make. That is worth the price of a piece of card, which is, of course, nothing.

I still have the chicken-and-lemon one. It is on the fridge, held by a magnet shaped like a strawberry. I am not going to cook it. But I like knowing it's there — a small, stubborn, printed vote of confidence in a version of me who has the timing right and the lemons in.

All Articles

Related Articles

The Slow Lane to Somewhere Slightly Ridiculous: In Defence of Britain’s Roadside Oddities

The Slow Lane to Somewhere Slightly Ridiculous: In Defence of Britain’s Roadside Oddities

The Exact-Change Test: Inside the Roadside Honesty Box Where Trust Has a Price and It’s Usually £2.50

The Exact-Change Test: Inside the Roadside Honesty Box Where Trust Has a Price and It’s Usually £2.50

The Two-Penny Theatre: A Small Defence of the Seaside Penny Falls

The Two-Penny Theatre: A Small Defence of the Seaside Penny Falls